Hiring the Best Talent: The Subtle Art of Humility in Job Descriptions

Hiring the best talent is no easy feat. It's not just about filling a seat or checking off qualifications from a list. It’s about understanding the intricate nuances of the profession, showing respect for the work, and creating a space where top-tier professionals can thrive. And, while it might sound simple, it’s actually a lot more complex—and a lot more humbling—than most companies realize.

Let’s break down how this works, starting with how you write your job description.

---

1. Understanding the Profession

When you’re crafting a job description, it’s easy to get caught up in the flashy requirements: the "must-have" skills, the "fast-paced environment" jargon, and the "dynamic team" pitch. But, underneath all that noise, the most important thing you need to do is acknowledge the core of the profession.

Think about it: every profession, whether it's software development, marketing, or finance, has its own set of challenges, nuances, and skills that go far beyond the basic list of qualifications. If you're hiring a data analyst, for instance, it’s not just about knowing Excel and SQL. It's about understanding how data impacts business decisions, how it drives growth, and how it can be transformed into actionable insights.

When writing the job description, show that you get it. You don’t need to be an expert, but you do need to convey that you understand the fundamental value of the role. Say something like:

- “We’re looking for someone who understands the power of data and knows how to translate it into strategies that drive success.”

It doesn’t need to be perfect. But it should come from a place of genuine understanding. You're not just checking a box of technical skills—you’re embracing the broader picture of what the role actually means.

---

2. Respecting the Profession

Once you’ve got a grip on the profession itself, the next step is to respect it. You don’t need to act like an expert in every role you’re hiring for (because, honestly, most of us aren’t), but you do need to acknowledge the importance of the expertise you're seeking.

It’s about recognizing that certain skills take years to master. A great designer isn’t just someone who can use Photoshop; they’re someone who understands the art and psychology behind good design. A great programmer isn’t just someone who can code—they’re someone who knows the ins and outs of algorithms, user experience, and system architecture.

In your job descriptions, reflect that respect for their craft. For instance:

- “We value the years of experience it takes to truly master your craft, and we’re excited to see how you can bring that knowledge to our team.”

That’s respect. Not just about checking boxes, but about appreciating the time, effort, and skill that goes into mastering the profession.

---

3. Willingness to Learn from the Profession

Here’s where things get a little more interesting. Humility plays a big part in hiring the best talent. When you’re writing that job description, consider this: the person you're hiring probably knows more about their profession than you do. And that’s okay.

Now, don’t panic. This isn’t about being less confident in your own abilities—it’s about recognizing that great professionals are always learning, and that their expertise is something you can learn from too.

Your job description doesn’t need to be a list of demands; it can be an invitation to collaboration. For example:

- “We’re looking for someone who can not only bring their expertise but also help us understand and improve our processes along the way.”

This communicates that you’re open to learning from them. You’re not pretending to be the expert—you’re showing that you understand there’s always room to grow, and that you want them to teach you.

---

4. Clarity on the Role and What It Involves

Finally, let’s talk about clarity. One of the biggest mistakes companies make in job descriptions is failing to clearly explain what the person will actually be doing. It’s easy to get caught up in buzzwords like “dynamic environment” and “multi-tasking required” without ever really addressing the core of the role.

If you truly understand the profession and respect it, then you should be able to articulate what the role will involve in a way that resonates with the candidate. For instance, instead of saying:

- “We’re looking for a Rockstar Developer who can work on all aspects of the product” 

Try:

- “We need someone who will help us take our product from good to great by building clean, scalable code that can stand up to the challenges of a growing business. You’ll work closely with our design and product teams to turn ideas into reality.”

By being clear, you show that you understand the job, the challenges, and what success looks like in that role. You’re not just listing generic tasks; you’re offering a window into what it truly means to be in that position.

---

The Shift: Understanding That They Know More Than You Do

So, let’s pause for a second. Here’s the hard truth that may feel a little uncomfortable:

The best candidates you’re looking to hire? They probably know more about their profession than you do.

Let it sink in.

Yes, I’m talking about that rockstar candidate you’ve been drooling over, the one with all the right qualifications, experience, and maybe even a secret talent for making great coffee. They probably know more about the job they’re doing than you could ever hope to understand. And guess what? That’s exactly what you want.  

I can already hear the collective gasps from hiring managers everywhere: “Wait... What? I’m supposed to be the expert!” Well, spoiler alert—you're not. At least not about their profession. And that's a game-changer when it comes to talent acquisition. 

Now, before you go running to the nearest HR conference with your arms raised in defeat, let’s break down the implications of this tectonic realization—because it’s going to rock your world, and, hopefully, your hiring process.  

I know. It’s a tough pill to swallow. But here’s the good news: this realization is a game-changer. Instead of thinking you need to be the expert in every field, start seeing yourself as the learner. 

This shift in mindset is essential. It's about moving away from evangelical culture pitches and hyperbolic claims, and moving toward a place where you're genuinely open to learning from the experts you hire. This humility can lead to stronger connections, better hires, and a deeper appreciation for the talent you're bringing on board.

---

The Humility of Hiring: They Know More Than You Do (And That’s Okay!)  

So here’s the hard truth: The person you're hiring is the expert. They're the one who’s spent years perfecting their craft, dealing with all the nuances, weird client requests, and ever-evolving tech or industry trends that make their job both a challenge and an art. But you? You’re just lucky enough to get to learn from them.

And let’s not sugarcoat this—it’s not just about the fact that they know more than you. It’s about the humility you need to embrace in order to respect their expertise.  

Example:  

Imagine you’re hiring a software developer. Instead of just listing "must know JavaScript, Python, React," and hoping for the best, you’ve got to acknowledge that this person is probably obsessed with their craft. They've spent years experimenting with frameworks, debugging issues you can’t even pronounce, and reading tech blogs that might as well be written in another language for you. Their code isn’t just functional; it’s elegant. Their approach isn’t just effective; it’s artistic. 

So when you’re writing your job description, drop the buzzwords and the empty slogans about how great your culture is. Instead, show a little respect.  

- “We’re looking for someone who can bring their deep knowledge of programming to help us solve real-world problems.”  

- “We know you probably have insights we haven’t even thought of—teach us, and let’s work together to make our product better.”  

Notice the difference? That’s humility at work. Because you’ve acknowledged that the candidate knows more than you. And that’s exactly the mindset you need for hiring the best.

---

Forget Evangelism, Embrace Real Talk  

Okay, now that we've gotten over the initial shock, let’s move on to how this humility shapes the rest of your hiring process, starting with the interview.  

Instead of sitting down for a one-sided grilling where you blast your carefully constructed list of qualifications, try this:

- Ask questions that show you want to learn from them.  

- Show interest in their expertise, and let them talk.  

- Be open to the fact that they might know better than you when it comes to certain aspects of the role.

Remember: The interview is not just about you deciding if they’re a good fit. It’s also about them deciding if your company is the right place for them to continue growing their skills. And to attract top talent, you need to prove that you’re willing to listen, learn, and adapt.

Example:  

Instead of:  

- “What are your weaknesses?”  

Try:  

- “What’s something you wish more companies understood about your profession?”  

And be prepared to hear the answer—because, spoiler alert, it’ll probably be your company.   

---

Onboarding: Don’t Be That Company That’s “Too Cool for School”  

So, you’ve hired your new genius. Congrats! Now, the real fun begins. How do you onboard someone who knows more than you? It’s not as scary as it sounds, I promise. But here’s the catch: Don’t assume they need to be “trained.” They don’t.  

What they need is context. Help them understand the company culture, the vision, and how they fit into the bigger picture. They’re already the expert in their field; they’re just figuring out how to make that expertise work with your team.  

- Don’t micromanage their expertise. If you hired someone for their skills, let them use those skills.  

- Ask for their input. They’re likely to have valuable suggestions about how to improve processes, tools, or workflows you never even considered.  

- Give them space to teach you. Be open to learning from them—and if they suggest a better way to do something, be humble enough to try it. 

---

 Retention: Hold On to That Genius, Don’t Let Them Slip Away  

Alright, so you’ve done the work to hire the best talent, and you’ve done your part to onboard them in a way that respects their expertise. Now, the next challenge: keeping them.  

How do you retain top talent? The answer is simple: keep being humble. Keep learning. Keep showing them that they’re valued for what they know—and that their opinions matter.  

 Example:  

- If you want to keep your developers happy, don’t just throw money at them. (They probably already have the skills to make bank at another company.)  

- Keep them engaged by offering opportunities to teach, lead, and innovate. Make them feel like their expertise isn’t just being used—it’s being celebrated.  

- And never, ever stop learning from them. The best employees are the ones who grow within your company. And that means you need to keep evolving as well.  

---

Hiring great talent is not about selling your company or your culture. It’s about respecting the fact that the best professionals know more than you—and that’s okay. When you embrace that humility, your job descriptions get better, your interviews become more meaningful, and your onboarding is less about “training” and more about integration.  

And, most importantly, your company will attract the people who will make it great—because you’re showing them the respect and humility they deserve.  

So, take a deep breath, ditch the corporate jargon, and start treating your candidates as the experts they are. You might just be surprised at what happens next.

---

The Interview: A Humble Conversation

Once you’ve embraced this humility, the interview process becomes a two-way conversation. You’re not just evaluating them—you’re both evaluating whether this is the right fit for mutual growth.

The best candidates don’t want to be talked down to—they want to know that your company is a place where they can contribute, teach, and grow. They want to feel respected as professionals, not just as resources to check off a hiring list.

---

Retention: Continuing the Humility Journey

And when you’ve hired that top talent, don’t stop there. Keep learning from them. Create an environment where they feel like they can continue to teach you. Foster an atmosphere of collaboration, where the sharing of knowledge and skills is a continuous process.

---

Conclusion: It’s All About Humility and Respect

To truly hire the best talent, you need more than just a checklist of qualifications—you need humility. You need to approach the job description with an understanding that the person you’re hiring might know more about their profession than you do, and that’s something to celebrate.

When you respect their expertise, acknowledge the value they bring, and invite them to teach you, your hiring process becomes about collaboration, not just filling a role. And that, my friends, is how you attract—and retain—the best talent on the market. 

So, go ahead, rewrite that job description with humility in mind. You might just find that the perfect candidate is waiting for you to show them the respect they deserve.